This, the fourth episode in our Christmas reading journey, sees three more, very different books read by Dr Hundal, Head of a Sixth Form House and biologist, and me. Dr Hundal’s chosen novel is entitled Butcher’s Crossing, and was written by John Williams in 1960. Williams’s book Stoner enjoyed renewed success in 2013, forty eight years after it was written, perhaps Butcher’s Crossing will too, some fifty five years later! Dr Hundal says:
“A terrific read which is set in the 1870s. It is written with a simple but engaging descriptive prose. The story’s central character is a young East Coast man going out West in search of adventure. After teaming up to hunt down one of the largest buffalo herds remaining, he finds he has taken on more than he bargained for. The tension between the main characters is at the heart of the book. I enjoyed the wonderful description of the wide, open and, at times, mountainous wilderness. Well recommended.”
The book was reviewed in The Guardian newspaper on 7th January 2014 by Nicholas Lezard and, he, too, was impressed by the novel. Click here to read more.
The two books which I spent my holidays reading are Jane Austen’s timeless Persuasion and Matt Haig’s current and most recently published Reasons for living. Both were read with different expectations.
Persuasion is my favourite of Austen’s novels, and thinking that I would have the time to do it justice, I began to read. Having read so many modern novels of various genres lately and not reading the great classics for a good few years, I found it took a little time for my brain to settle and focus on the language, manners and expressions. I had thought that I would be able to slip into it again, and the fact that I didn’t, and felt that I had to engage my brain physically to do so, made me think that this could be an excellent brain exercise! I was justly rewarded and reminded of what a great novel it is. I have recently seen an article which considers Persuasion the poorest of Austen’s work but I’m sure I don’t agree. Perhaps I am not viewing it critically and just enjoying the story, the setting and language. That’s good enough for me! It’s a wonderful novel about true friendship, the nature of families, love, and the way life turns out – not so different from many modern novels but also a commentary on its time, where making good marriages did count for some. we learn how a man could establish himself as a naval officer and earn the respect and wealth which goes with hard work, and, interestingly, become rich through being a captain in times of war. Give me a Captain Wentworth any day!
I chose my next book having read a review somewhere (I really must start making notes of where I read such things!), and felt the need to take a look at Matt Haig‘s book to understand exactly what he went through as a young man of 24 who found himself extremely depressed with very little hope about what the future may bring. He tells how he came through his darkest times and discusses how mindfulness has become a key part of his recovery. The more I learn of this idea, the more I like, and can see how beneficial it can be. I had heard of Haig as an author of children’s and young adult fiction, and wanted to know more about him. I truly appreciated this book and learned more from it than I have from other sources, produced by clinicians. It is an honest account of how he has come through and taught me a few things:
“That’s the odd thing about depression and anxiety. It acts like an intense fear of happiness, even as you yourself consciously want that happiness more than anything…”
His list of reasons for staying alive halfway through the book makes so much sense to me, even as a non-sufferer. This book helps those who love people who are.
I’d be interested in reading your thoughts, if you have read any of these books, do let me know!