At our last meeting, we discussed three novels, all very different in style and content. First on our list was the challenge of a male member of the club: ‘Women don’t read John le Carré’, so we read le Carré’s novel A Murder of Quality. Given that the majority of us are women, we took up the challenge! On the whole, we enjoyed the novel very much, despite the unattractive group of characters and the dismal time of year when the murder took place. We felt it was cleverly written, its spare, minimalist prose built up the tension and drama. It left us wondering whose side is le Carré on… Smiley is acting in a more detective-like role, but is nonetheless as effective as when he is the spy.
Shirley Jackson’s We Have Always Lived in the Castle was a completely different genre. Some found it bizarrely compelling, with others not liking it at all. It was well-written but clearly a reflection of Jackson’s turbulent mind, with the symbiotic relationships between the sisters, and other characters. The tale portrays small town America in an unfavourable light, however the descriptions of the surroundings of the castle are almost poetic.
Our third novel was The Secret Place by Tana French. Most readers enjoyed it very much, although the supernatural element to the tale appeared superfluous. The story revolves around the relationships between girls at an independent girls’ boarding school in Dublin and the murder of a boy from the corresponding boys’ school, on the grounds of the former school. We are told the story both from the girls’ perspective and that of the young male detective, who is striving to make his mark in the murder squad. Interesting, strange and holds the attention.
We also discussed other books which we had read over the summer and I include these for your reference as books which you may wish to include on your Christmas lists:
- Atlas Shrugged by Ayn Rand click here for a link to a website dedicated to this book. Hilary recommended it and Sarah read it during the break. Discussion of the novel was very interesting with Patrick and Hilary representing opposing views about Rand and her theories, philosophies and ideas on economics and the workings of the world. Fascinating stuff!
- The President’s Hat by Antoine Laurin – (read in translation from the French). Again, the book has its own website, click on the book title to go there. This was a great little book about the positive impact that François Mitterand’s hat has on the lives of four different individuals after they have worn it… A light but entertaining read!
- We are all completely besides ourselves by Karen Joy Fowler – this was another curious summer read for Beth and me, well-written story, although a bit strange. It’s very different from The Jane Austen book club, one of the author’s previous works.
- Shadowlands by William Nicholson: Kafka-esque.
- Probably nothing : a diary of not-your-average nine months by Matilda Tristram. A graphic novel written by a woman who had been diagnosed with cancer, about her experiences
- Novels by the late P D James
- Books by Antonia Senior
- Books by Philippa Gregory
- Goldfinch by Donna Tartt
- Books by Gerald Seymour
- The house we grew up in by Lisa Jewell
- Books by Louis Theroux
We won’t be meeting again until after Christmas – so here’s wishing all the greetings of the season and enjoy the holidays!